Jul -- Computers and Technology: Windows 7 vs Windows XP

Bagel

Giant Red Paratroopa
without music life would Bb
Level: 75

Posts: 861/1446
EXP: 3802210
For next: 24694

Since: 03-30-09

Pronouns: he/him
From: bear

Since last post: 190 days
Last activity: 6 days

Posted on 02-10-11 04:46:39 PM

Link | Quote

XP is approaching the age of ten years. It is only still in use because the original release of Vista was unresponsive and had compatibility problems, and even after two service packs ended up being really bloated. Vista's original negative reputation at release time plagued its entire lifespan even though Service Pack 1 made a huge difference, so XP is still the dominant version of Windows.

Windows 7, while not itself bloat-free, is still as fast as XP in almost any situation, and in some situations is even faster. It's also been more stable than XP ever has been in my experience. XP also feels like I'm using something primitive in comparison, somehow.

I only use Windows for games, though. It'd be a waste of my video card and RAM to run XP when I can use a version of Windows with DirectX 10/11 support and a larger addressing space. Windows 7 gets my vote. Hell, Vista would be okay, too, I suppose, since I end up not actually using Windows at all, just Steam running on top of it.

____________________

Peardian

Magikoopa

16/3/1: KvSG #479 is up!

Level: 157

Posts: 4524/7597
EXP: 48602983
For next: 976250

Since: 08-02-07

From: Isle Delfino

Since last post: 10 days
Last activity: 13 hours

Posted on 02-10-11 04:56:13 PM

Link | Quote

I still use XP and am quite used to its style of organizing files and such. However, I must say I really like the improvements in 7's interface, notably the ability to quickly stick windows to fullscreen/halfscreen by dragging it near the edges. Previews of the windows shown in the taskbar and outlines when switching windows is really useful when you have a lot open. Upgrading to it from XP will take getting used to, as will any change, but it will be worth it.

____________________
-Peardian-

"Kindness is the language which the deaf can hear and the blind can see." -Mark Twain
Galaxy Complete!

paulguy

Green Birdo
Level: 93

Posts: 1283/2294
EXP: 8032378
For next: 20432

Since: 09-14-07

From: Buffalo, NY

Since last post: 9.7 years
Last activity: 9.7 years

Posted on 02-10-11 05:25:04 PM

Link | Quote

Paulguy's Post configuration

I prefer 7. Quick, modern and decent compatibility with newer hardware/software. XP is also way to reminiscent of like, early 2000s era horrible crap cheap machines (emachines, gateway). 7 is also a decent step towards improved system security. Still not great, but a definite step in the right direction.

____________________

Aerakin
Ye Olde Layout
Level: 98

Posts: 2274/2550
EXP: 9475909
For next: 178444

Since: 07-06-07

From: From the future

Since last post: 8.0 years
Last activity: 1.2 years

Posted on 02-10-11 05:29:03 PM

Link | Quote

Windows 7, definitely (unless it is something like Starter, which is just stupid)

Vista also wasn't that bad, after about a million obscure tweaks :specialed:

____________________
"Water is the best way to buy time" ~Day9

Bagel

Giant Red Paratroopa
without music life would Bb
Level: 75

Posts: 862/1446
EXP: 3802210
For next: 24694

Since: 03-30-09

Pronouns: he/him
From: bear

Since last post: 190 days
Last activity: 6 days

Posted on 02-10-11 05:37:49 PM (last edited by Bagel at 02-10-11 02:39 PM)

Link | Quote

Originally posted by Peardian's comment
That said, I'm sticking to XP as long as I can, because I don't want to have to re-install everything.

That brings up something I've always wondered about. How much software do people have that actually requires a formal installation? I'm not used to Windows for daily use anymore and I barely use anything that is "installed" (with like ... a wizard) at all with it.

For me, if I got a new machine or something, after running Windows Update, I'd just toss my steamapps folder and maybe some savefiles on a backup drive and ... I'm done. If I got a new machine I'd just install Steam, put the backed-up steamapps folder into the Steam directory, launch Steam, and I'd be like 90% done. After that I'd just download Firefox and MSE, adjust some of Windows' annoying defaults to more reasonable settings, and I'd be good to go.

____________________

Sine
2310

Level: 94

Posts: 2222/2316
EXP: 8200628
For next: 156029

Since: 07-07-07

Since last post: 3.7 years
Last activity: 289 days

Posted on 02-10-11 05:39:44 PM

Link | Quote

It's an enigma
----------------------------------------------------

Originally posted by Peardian

www.ninite.com should take care of... 80-90% of the basics.

At this point, I jump between 7 on my desktop to linux on my laptop. Been using 7 ever since it came out though... and even in Beta. Runs better on my hardware than XP ever did.

____________________
00:00 2/7/10

— Bloodstar —
11360

Buy me a trip to the moon
So I can laugh at my mistakes

Post 8162/11363

Joined 07-06-07
Active 1 day ago

Posted on 02-10-11 05:52:25 PM

Link | Quote

Nobody's ever done a foxgirl, to my knowledge. And Disgaea's awesome, so... yeah.

XP by far.

Windows 7 is nice and usable, and the UI makes XP feel primitive unless you use visual styles. However, my experience with 7... varies, and unfortunately it's more bad than good. Stability overall is a step down from XP (but only a step - it's not like you take a cinder block to the OS and smash it), wireless issues plague my portables, and apparently if the files aren't on very specific positions on the HD you might as well just consider all your files wiped. (This was the killer for me. The HD is fine - XP and Ubuntu have been running on it with absolute zero issue after that explosion.)

What I can say is... when 7 wants to behave, it behaves. And quite well. But, unfortunately, for me this isn't all the time.

____________________
BMF IS A LEAPFROG

Liliana
"A horrible person". That's what it says. "A horrible person."

We weren't even testing for that.

Level: NaN

Posts: 2216/-3841
EXP: NaN
For next: 0

Since: 07-23-07

Since last post: 10.3 years
Last activity: 10.1 years

Posted on 02-10-11 05:57:22 PM

Link | Quote

Windows 7 broke Unicode. That is an immediate no-go for me as I need it for my work.

Windows XP, patched with Vista SP1 files seems to be the way to go.

____________________

Most people who visit your Web pages are there in search of useful or entertaining information, not to admire your fancy graphics skills or HTML prowess.
— Apple Web Design Guide, 1996

PYRATROOPER
Game over, asshole.
Level: 35

Posts: 100/255
EXP: 261471
For next: 18465

Since: 01-18-11

From: A GALAXY FAR FAR AWAY

Since last post: 11.1 years
Last activity: 11.1 years

Posted on 02-10-11 06:33:29 PM

Link | Quote

Originally posted by Prince Kassad
Windows XP, patched with Vista SP1 files seems to be the way to go.[/quote

How do you pull that off?

____________________
PYRABOARD

Elemi
370

"ban me or whatever"

Okay, bye, please don't push your antivax shit here
Level: 42

Posts: 18/379
EXP: 485761
For next: 35601

Since: 06-20-10

Pronouns: She/her
From: Hyperspace

Since last post: 3.1 years
Last activity: 2.4 years

Posted on 02-10-11 06:35:13 PM

Link | Quote

For the kind of stuff I do, Windows XP is the best.
As for 7, It is good, but lacks the features and support for various things I need.

dotUser
From the Grave
Level: 91

Posts: 162/2357
EXP: 7427623
For next: 41289

Since: 10-20-10

Pronouns: she/her
From: a particularly peculiar tiny store's back shelf

Since last post: 34 days
Last activity: 6 days

Posted on 02-10-11 06:59:57 PM

Link | Quote

I find it funny people use the argument that Vista7 uses less resources and doesn't support certain things which I always managed to get working on my XP. I personally would prefer XP largely because I am used to it, plus it never annoyed me with notices and asking me all the time if I really wanted something to run. It was obedient to my needs.

...Up until my tower suddenly decided to refuse it entirely.

All my experiences with Vista7 only made me dislike it more as well. Many of the things I liked to control in XP are harder to locate or removed even. If my machine would accept XP again I'd probably be happier with it too since they are changing the autorun handling for it as well.

And yes, I call Windows7 Vista7. Deal with it >:T

____________________

Social: Tumblr / Twitter / Website

Liliana
"A horrible person". That's what it says. "A horrible person."

We weren't even testing for that.

Level: NaN

Posts: 2217/-3841
EXP: NaN
For next: 0

Since: 07-23-07

Since last post: 10.3 years
Last activity: 10.1 years

Posted on 02-10-11 07:18:05 PM

Link | Quote

Originally posted by PYRATROOPER
How do you pull that off?

Certain files from Vista SP1 work in XP as well if you copy them over. You first need to kill off the system file protection of XP, then you can just do a copy-paste.

____________________

Most people who visit your Web pages are there in search of useful or entertaining information, not to admire your fancy graphics skills or HTML prowess.
— Apple Web Design Guide, 1996

Lyskar
12210

-The Chaos within trumps the Chaos without-
Level: 192

Posts: 8245/12211
EXP: 99321263
For next: 552308

Since: 07-03-07

From: 52-2-88-7

Since last post: 7.4 years
Last activity: 7.3 years

Posted on 02-10-11 07:32:35 PM

Link | Quote

Stats

Time/Date
02-10-11 01:32:35 PM
Posts
8245
Days Here
1318
Level
133

Metal_Man88's Post

XP x64. It possesses some data from later versions of Windows and runs faster, and is also compatible with most new hardware. 'Primitive' UI can be fixed with the proper patching, although I prefer to keep it that way.

It can run pretty much anything 7 can, except the latest version of DirectX--but developers are slow to abandon XP, so it's unlikely that'll effect me.

Also, if you know all the shortcuts to it like I do, the improvements in 7 are not necessary at all. I can move stuff and stick it to places however I want to.

____________________

Eisnaught - SSQ² - Mobius Roleplay - SSS

Post 1213/1311 (41 days), online 1 day ago

Posted on 02-10-11 09:35:20 PM (last edited by Milly at 02-10-11 06:39 PM)

Link | Quote

#59

Reminds me when I replaced some of XP's files with 2000's, but not a lot of them worked

Windows XP for me as well, purely by choice (this quad core could easily handle Windows Vista or 7, and the only old hardware I have that might not work is my webcam from 2001) ... although that's more from experience with Vista at work, Windows 7 looking mostly the same except the new taskbar, and me being used to XP after 8 years

Of course, the XP I got to love after all this time has been tweaked quite a bit, and I'd be doing the same with Vista or 7, but there's still too many reasons not to update:

- I always hated Vista's buggy/bloated/uncustomizable Explorer (I don't want the breadcrumbs, command bar or search box, why can't I disable them? And why is the filesize display still broken after 2 service packs?), and 7's doesn't look like much of an improvement ... sure, XP's defaults sucked too, but it could at least be changed to this

- I don't want to infect my system with the winsxs virus (supposedly a "feature", but whatever), which tries to fix "DLL Hell" (when was it a problem on XP, again?) by introducing another hell, and eats gigabytes of disk space ... even though Vista seems to run fine with most of it gone (and more)

- Aero does look better than Fisher-Price, but I use classic anyway ... and if I wanted a theme that bad, a custom one on XP would do the job as well (minus the transparency)

- Most of the "new in Windows 7" features listed on microsoft.com (last I checked anyway) were things I can already do on XP or just don't care about

- When I tried Windows 7 RC1 (not sure if that still happens with RTM or SP1), my desktop background was blurred a bit

- I multitask on XP with under 1GB RAM usage most of the time, about what Windows 7 needs for the average startup (but I have 4GB anyway, and no use for more yet)

I admit I haven't really given Windows 7 a chance yet (barely tried RC1 or used any computer running it), and it does have some real improvements, but I just don't have enough reasons yet ... maybe when I'll really need 64bit, or too much stuff drops XP support, or if my next computer (in a few more years?) can't run XP

____________________

Nicole

she's more meow now than man, twisted and evil

Disk-kun
Level: 146

Posts: 2495/6469
EXP: 38284827
For next: 228467

Since: 07-07-07

Pronouns: she/her
From: Boston, MA

Since last post: 78 days
Last activity: 1 day

Posted on 02-10-11 09:39:10 PM

Link | Quote

Neither, I use Vista.

And I'm kind of serious there... I don't see any reason to upgrade this particular machine from Vista to 7, but on the other hand, Vista does have some improvements over XP that are worth having... (the search function is the first thing that comes to mind)

____________________

— Bloodstar —
11360

Buy me a trip to the moon
So I can laugh at my mistakes

Post 8164/11363

Joined 07-06-07
Active 1 day ago

Posted on 02-10-11 09:40:43 PM

Link | Quote

Originally posted by Milly
- When I tried Windows 7 RC1 (not sure if that still happens with RTM or SP1), my desktop background was blurred a bit

This does indeed happen. Very, very irritating - there's no possible reason it should be doing this, is there?

____________________
BMF IS A LEAPFROG

Aoi
Member
Level: 30

Posts: 119/181
EXP: 159813
For next: 6056

Since: 07-18-10

Since last post: 9.9 years
Last activity: 9.9 years

Posted on 02-10-11 09:47:15 PM

Link | Quote

I think I've read somewhere that Vista and Win7 automatically JPEG-compress the desktop background.

(Not that I've really noticed on either of my Vista setups, but then, I haven't paid close attention to the backgrounds.)

Prince Kassad: Win7 broke Unicode? How so?

Xenesis

Roy Koopa
Actually a Doctor
Level: 101

Posts: 974/2732
EXP: 10486678
For next: 230997

Since: 07-28-07

Pronouns: She/Her
From: Orange Star's Retirement Villa

Since last post: 9 days
Last activity: 21 hours

Posted on 02-10-11 09:51:08 PM

Link | Quote

Hrm.

I have Win7 on my Boot Camp partition (I managed to chance into a free copy of Win7 Pro). Considering that I have a computer with 4GB of ram now, moving to a 64-bit OS for my game playing seemed like a sensible idea.

It feels a bit cleaner than XP, but I still can't find some settings I've needed to change without extreme difficulty.

Danika
6230

Level: 141

Posts: 5541/6235
EXP: 33298174
For next: 821840

Since: 10-23-09

Since last post: 1.2 years
Last activity: 1.2 years

Posted on 02-10-11 11:57:34 PM

Link | Quote

00:00:00	KIP wishes you a Happy Easter!
POST # 5541	Windows 7 is now my new favorite (before that, it was Windows 2000)... looking forward to Windows 7 SP1 myself ____________________ Twitter • YouTube • DeviantArt • The Left Mouse Button "Oops! Don't step in the fire without fire boots!" ~Chip's Challenge

Register - Login
Views: 99803615	Main - Memberlist - Active users - Calendar - Wiki - IRC Chat - Online users Ranks - Rules/FAQ - Stats - Latest Posts - Color Chart - Smilies	05-03-22 07:24:59 AM

Query execution time:	0.143692 seconds
Script execution time:	0.056854 seconds
Total render time:	0.200546 seconds