Jul -- Meta: Why don't URLs automatically become links when posted?

Tiden
Disgusting human being, just awful
Level: NaN

Posts: 3505/-6493
EXP: NaN
For next: 0

Since: 07-03-07

Pronouns: they/them

Since last post: 4.1 years
Last activity: 3.6 years

Posted on 03-01-09 03:23:18 PM

Link | Quote

This isn't most forums.

Tina
Beep boop
Level: 79

Posts: 560/1549
EXP: 4471620
For next: 107847

Since: 08-10-07

Since last post: 3.4 years
Last activity: 3.4 years

Posted on 03-01-09 03:23:46 PM

Link | Quote

Because it is assumed that the user has enough knowledge to make their own URL code (either by using [url] or <a href>), not to mention being easily broken. Welcome to having freedom of using HTML.

____________________

Myon Beyond
Member
This Chen is so fabulous Chen!
Level: 43

Posts: 356/374
EXP: 531266
For next: 33780

Since: 07-26-07

From: Scarlet Devil Mansion

Since last post: 12.8 years
Last activity: 12.7 years

Posted on 03-01-09 03:25:06 PM

Link | Quote

That's really inconvenient.

Teconmoon
Catgirl
User 275
Level: 84

Posts: 1375/1772
EXP: 5452010
For next: 209942

Since: 09-17-07

From: Edmonds, WA

Since last post: 12.5 years
Last activity: 12.5 years

Posted on 03-01-09 03:26:34 PM

Link | Quote

[url]whatever[/url]

How inconvienient can that be?

Tina
Beep boop
Level: 79

Posts: 561/1549
EXP: 4471620
For next: 107847

Since: 08-10-07

Since last post: 3.4 years
Last activity: 3.4 years

Posted on 03-01-09 03:26:40 PM

Link | Quote

Opera also has a feature which allows you to highlight text and select "Go to URL", which is convinient.

____________________

Myon Beyond
Member
This Chen is so fabulous Chen!
Level: 43

Posts: 358/374
EXP: 531266
For next: 33780

Since: 07-26-07

From: Scarlet Devil Mansion

Since last post: 12.8 years
Last activity: 12.7 years

Posted on 03-01-09 03:31:28 PM (last edited by Myon Beyond at 03-01-09 12:32 PM)

Link | Quote

Originally posted by Teconmoon
[url]whatever[/url]
How inconvienient can that be?

In the amount of time it took me to put URL tags around the aforementioned URL, I could've posted it, typed something else, etc. It saves a lot of time, especially when dealing with multiple links in a single post. I don't see how you can argue this.

Tina
Beep boop
Level: 79

Posts: 562/1549
EXP: 4471620
For next: 107847

Since: 08-10-07

Since last post: 3.4 years
Last activity: 3.4 years

Posted on 03-01-09 03:33:43 PM

Link | Quote

Like I said, the problem arises because we allow HTML.

For example, pasting a URL into a link will create... another link. This goes for pretty much any sort of URL, since they have many purposes in HTML.

This forum doesn't, and likely won't, support it.

____________________

Myon Beyond
Member
This Chen is so fabulous Chen!
Level: 43

Posts: 360/374
EXP: 531266
For next: 33780

Since: 07-26-07

From: Scarlet Devil Mansion

Since last post: 12.8 years
Last activity: 12.7 years

Posted on 03-01-09 03:38:34 PM (last edited by Myon Beyond at 03-01-09 12:49 PM)

Link | Quote

Originally posted by Tina
Like I said, the problem arises because we allow HTML.

For example, pasting a URL into a link will create... another link. This goes for pretty much any sort of URL, since they have many purposes in HTML.

This forum doesn't, and likely won't, support it.

So there's no way to program the forum to automatically place URL tags around a link that doesn't have them, simply because the forum is set up to allow the use of HTML?

It really is nothing for me to put tags in myself, but Christ, it just seems so stupid to not have the feature.

Tina
Beep boop
Level: 79

Posts: 563/1549
EXP: 4471620
For next: 107847

Since: 08-10-07

Since last post: 3.4 years
Last activity: 3.4 years

Posted on 03-01-09 03:41:11 PM

Link | Quote

Unlike other forums, URLs are used in more than just the context of BBCode filler. Checking to see if it's already wrapped in [img][/img] or [url][/url] is simple; checking if it's in one of the myrad of ways you can use one in HTML isn't.

If you're seriously that upset over it, bug hydrapheetz.

____________________

Myon Beyond
Member
This Chen is so fabulous Chen!
Level: 43

Posts: 363/374
EXP: 531266
For next: 33780

Since: 07-26-07

From: Scarlet Devil Mansion

Since last post: 12.8 years
Last activity: 12.7 years

Posted on 03-01-09 03:56:24 PM (last edited by Myon Beyond at 03-01-09 12:56 PM)

Link | Quote

Originally posted by Tina
Unlike other forums, URLs are used in more than just the context of BBCode filler. Checking to see if it's already wrapped in [img][/img] or [url][/url] is simple; checking if it's in one of the myrad of ways you can use one in HTML isn't.

I meant to say "doesn't have them", if that means anything.

The fact of the matter is that a URL without URL tags around them is usually expected to automatically become a link unless coded otherwise. If this is not how you guys want things handled, then by all means carry on. You're not upsetting me or whatever. I just like being able to save time, and the position of keys required to type...

[url][/url] or <a href=""></a> or whatever

...makes the simple task of inserting a quick link in any post take longer than it normally does when I do it anywhere else on the internet.

Just saying. Close thread.

Tina
Beep boop
Level: 79

Posts: 564/1549
EXP: 4471620
For next: 107847

Since: 08-10-07

Since last post: 3.4 years
Last activity: 3.4 years

Posted on 03-01-09 03:59:08 PM

Link | Quote

Who knows, maybe when I fix the post toolbar I'll add a shortcut for ctrl-whatever.

____________________

Hiryuu

Level: 207

Posts: 7252/14435
EXP: 127622451
For next: 2161703

Since: 07-06-07

Since last post: 11.8 years
Last activity: 11.7 years

Posted on 03-01-09 06:08:28 PM

Link | Quote

Why?

Hell...look at X. Does he look less than lazy?

____________________

Lyskar
12210

-The Chaos within trumps the Chaos without-
Level: 192

Posts: 2204/12211
EXP: 99321441
For next: 552130

Since: 07-03-07

From: 52-2-88-7

Since last post: 7.4 years
Last activity: 7.3 years

Posted on 03-01-09 08:12:01 PM

Link | Quote

Time/Date

03-01-09 02:12:01pm

Posts

2204

Days Here

607

Level

67

	Metal_Man88
	Local Moderator

Dammit, where is an animated icon that expresses 'You are a nit picker' when you need one?

____________________

Original Layout © Tobias Kelmandia

Tanks

360? Yessum.
Level: 121

Posts: 2187/4170
EXP: 19808690
For next: 248006

Since: 07-10-07

From: VA

Since last post: 9.5 years
Last activity: 9.5 years

Posted on 03-01-09 08:16:06 PM

Link | Quote

Originally posted by Metal_Man88
Dammit, where is an animated icon that expresses 'You are a nit picker' when you need one?

:radsigh:

____________________

Tiden
Disgusting human being, just awful
Level: NaN

Posts: 3507/-6493
EXP: NaN
For next: 0

Since: 07-03-07

Pronouns: they/them

Since last post: 4.1 years
Last activity: 3.6 years

Posted on 03-01-09 08:20:25 PM

Link | Quote

Tina
Beep boop
Level: 79

Posts: 565/1549
EXP: 4471620
For next: 107847

Since: 08-10-07

Since last post: 3.4 years
Last activity: 3.4 years

Posted on 03-01-09 09:25:50 PM

Link | Quote

____________________

Teconmoon
Catgirl
User 275
Level: 84

Posts: 1378/1772
EXP: 5452010
For next: 209942

Since: 09-17-07

From: Edmonds, WA

Since last post: 12.5 years
Last activity: 12.5 years

Posted on 03-01-09 09:43:59 PM

Link | Quote

Originally posted by Myon Beyond

Lenophis

Level: 15

Posts: 19/34
EXP: 13924
For next: 2460

Since: 10-30-08

Since last post: 13.1 years
Last activity: 12.0 years

Posted on 03-07-09 03:09:07 AM (last edited by Lenophis at 03-07-09 12:37 AM)

Link | Quote

And yet all of this is a non-issue if you are using Linkification.

Originally posted by Myon Beyond
Originally posted by Teconmoon
[url]whatever[/url]
How inconvienient can that be?
In the amount of time it took me to put URL tags around the aforementioned URL, I could've posted it, typed something else, etc. It saves a lot of time, especially when dealing with multiple links in a single post.

You must be a slow typer...

____________________

To see a list of all of the bugs we've fixed so far, check here. 100 bugs and counting!

CarCat

Level: 51

Posts: 555/572
EXP: 997018
For next: 16920

Since: 10-17-07

From: LA

Since last post: 13.0 years
Last activity: 11.9 years

Posted on 03-07-09 04:01:18 AM

Link | Quote

I'm sure if this were in the original coding, none of you would be complaining to remove it in favor of Mozilla's system. It's a feature request people! There will always be a turn around, or short cut, or alternative, or just another way of doing it. Posting alternatives in this thread will not change the fact that there isn't a feature in the board to do it, it simply masks the problem. Complaining that said requester is lazy to me is not justification for not attempting to make such a thing under the convenience of others!

Register - Login
Views: 99805516	Main - Memberlist - Active users - Calendar - Wiki - IRC Chat - Online users Ranks - Rules/FAQ - Stats - Latest Posts - Color Chart - Smilies	05-03-22 07:52:58 AM

Query execution time:	0.096074 seconds
Script execution time:	0.035028 seconds
Total render time:	0.131102 seconds