Register - Login
Views: 95451300
Main - Memberlist - Active users - Calendar - Wiki - IRC Chat - Online users
Ranks - Rules/FAQ - Stats - Latest Posts - Color Chart - Smilies
10-19-18 06:01:54 AM

Jul - Computers and Technology - Reliable hard drive models & manufacturers? New poll - New thread - New reply
Next newer thread | Next older thread
xdaniel
770
Level: 55


Posts: 715/772
EXP: 1288035
For next: 26154

Since: 12-04-08

Pronouns: he/him
From: Germany

Since last post: 8 days
Last activity: 12 hours

Posted on 02-18-18 02:57:33 PM Link | Quote
My 500 GB Seagate hard drive gave me a wonderful birthday present today! It died. Taking along a ton of music, ROMs, backups, and so on. It's no longer recognized on bootup; it doesn't even output anything over serial, while another 40 GB Seagate I have does.

So, I need a replacement - one that's not too terribly expensive, but also not likely to fail within the first year or two. But the last drive I bought was my 1 TB Samsung Spinpoint (still in good health!) back in 2010, so I have no idea which manufacturers and models today are good, which are bad, or hell, which ones still exist! Samsung doesn't make 'em anymore, apparently their HDD business was bought by Seagate.

Looking around, the only(?) manufacturers these days are Seagate, WD and Toshiba, and... all three seem to be a bit of a crapshoot? With drives said to be failing or getting slower after very short periods of time, and in turn people recommending staying away from one brand and getting one from the other, while other people say the opposite, etc...

On the positive side, since there's only these three left, making a shortlist of drives was easy - all are 2 TB, SATA 3 (6 Gb/s), 3.5" and not too expensive (around 60 Euro):

- Seagate Barracuda (ST2000DM006)
- WD Blue (WD20EZRZ)
- Toshiba P300 (HDWD130[?])

...now which one would you recommend, tho? I'm seeing similar reviews and such for all three of these. Do you have any of these, or any similar drives from the same manufacturer? Have you been happy with the drive or had any issues?
andlabs
Member
Level: 35


Posts: 285/290
EXP: 276572
For next: 3364

Since: 03-18-10

From: United States

Since last post: 38 days
Last activity: 7 days

Posted on 02-18-18 03:06:01 PM Link | Quote
I have had no issues with Western Digital drives so far. I will say you should only go for internal drives, and I have the software project to explain why.
Joe
Common spammer
🍬
Level: 105


Posts: 3295/3306
EXP: 12165933
For next: 96327

Since: 08-02-07

From: Pororoca

Since last post: 32 days
Last activity: 8 min.

Posted on 02-18-18 05:50:41 PM Link | Quote
I work in a datacenter.

There's basically no correlation between manufacturer and reliability, nor is there any correlation between the reliability of one model and the reliability of another.

Back up your data.
xdaniel
770
Level: 55


Posts: 716/772
EXP: 1288035
For next: 26154

Since: 12-04-08

Pronouns: he/him
From: Germany

Since last post: 8 days
Last activity: 12 hours

Posted on 02-18-18 06:03:20 PM (last edited by xdaniel at 02-18-18 06:05:56 PM) Link | Quote
...yeah, the "back up your data" part is where I failed hard. Hell, I did notice CrystalDiskInfo showing me a freaking health warning for the drive, but I was dragging my feet! And that's what I get, very much deservedly so, I guess...

Anyway, I'll see if I can pick up a new drive in town tomorrow, otherwise I'll order one on Amazon. As for backups, what I'm thinking is to...

1) Install the new drive, gather all the important data I want/need to be backed up on it.
2) Next month (because cost), get another drive of the same size - either an external drive (tho not a WD as per andlabs), or an internal one plus a USB 3.0 enclosure.
3) Run regular, (semi-)automated backups from the new internal drive to the external drive, and only use the external drive to store that backup data.

...and 4), in case of another catastrophic failure, have the external drive (with at worst minor data loss) ready to copy its contents back to a new internal drive.

Does that sound sensible?
Kazinsal
Amazing Flyin' Hammer Bro
Level: 48


Posts: 584/615
EXP: 811384
For next: 12159

Since: 01-18-11

Pronouns: he/him
From: Victoria, Canada

Since last post: 4 hours
Last activity: 3 hours

Posted on 02-18-18 06:49:16 PM Link | Quote
Originally posted by Joe
I work in a datacenter.

There's basically no correlation between manufacturer and reliability, nor is there any correlation between the reliability of one model and the reliability of another.

Back up your data.


Seconding this. They're all good these days. I've got a mix of WDs and Seagates spread over the past five years in my machine -- some enterprise, some not -- and haven't had problems with any of them.
Lunaria

Moon Bunny! :3
Level: 132


Posts: 5472/5607
EXP: 26886094
For next: 245839

Since: 07-28-07

Pronouns: she/her
From: pile of fluff

Since last post: 8 hours
Last activity: 8 hours

Posted on 02-18-18 07:55:59 PM Link | Quote
HHDs have a small failure rate from factory production, like, a few disks per batch is bad and they die within the first few years. But you can't really know that when you get them, it's worth it to plan around it even if you're very, very, unlikely to get one of the bad ones when you buy them.

Like, IIRC, it's was either around 0.2% or 0.02% of disks.

But yeah, just buy whatever brand, shouldn't be that bad.
xdaniel
770
Level: 55


Posts: 717/772
EXP: 1288035
For next: 26154

Since: 12-04-08

Pronouns: he/him
From: Germany

Since last post: 8 days
Last activity: 12 hours

Posted on 02-19-18 01:04:02 PM Link | Quote
Thanks for the information and reassurance. I ended up going for the 2 TB WD Blue (WD20EZRZ-00Z5HB0) because it was in stock at a local store for 63 Euro. Installed it about 3 hours ago, and am now shoveling data onto it, tho nothing irreplaceable quite yet, just in the unlikely event it might be a dud.

I also am most likely going to go the "get another drive next month for regular backups, and only backups" route; probably another WD Blue like this one, plus a USB 3.0 enclosure for it.
Zeether

Level: 30


Posts: 217/219
EXP: 152574
For next: 13295

Since: 09-23-12


Since last post: 42 days
Last activity: 22 days

Posted on 08-21-18 07:29:57 AM Link | Quote
I quit using Seagate after one drive I had kept making nasty noises and eventually failed. I always keep stuff backed up externally though, around every 4 months or so I run a backup.
dotUser

Level: 86


Posts: 2308/2319
EXP: 6035916
For next: 106191

Since: 10-19-10

Pronouns: she/her, they/them
From: a particularly peculiar tiny store's back shelf

Since last post: 1 day
Last activity: 8 hours

Posted on 08-23-18 09:09:00 PM Link | Quote
Originally posted by Zeether
I quit using Seagate after one drive ...


I quit using WD after one drive, too...

Gabu

Star Mario
Placeholder Ikachan until :effort: is found
Level: 164


Posts: 9854/9865
EXP: 56771080
For next: 931310

Since: 08-10-09

Pronouns: they/them, she/her
From: Santa Cruisin' USA

Since last post: 5 days
Last activity: 5 hours

Posted on 09-02-18 03:50:10 PM Link | Quote
I've two Seagate hard drives, one 1 TB bought in 2009 that Defraggler is noting that it could go in the next year or two, and a 5 TB one that I deadass almost bricked.

Don't defrag under the influence, but on the flip side, it did help that I kept calm during the kerfuffle. But I am gonna keep an eye on it.
Next newer thread | Next older thread
Jul - Computers and Technology - Reliable hard drive models & manufacturers? New poll - New thread - New reply




Rusted Logic

Acmlmboard - commit 5d36857 [2018-03-03]
©2000-2018 Acmlm, Xkeeper, Inuyasha, et al.

29 database queries.
Query execution time: 0.181861 seconds
Script execution time: 0.016292 seconds
Total render time: 0.198153 seconds
Memory used: 1310720