Jul -- The Cutting Room Floor: Mega Man Legacy Collection

Register - Login
Views: 90675236	Main - Memberlist - Active users - Calendar - Wiki - IRC Chat - Online users Ranks - Rules/FAQ - Stats - Latest Posts - Color Chart - Smilies	04-26-18 07:01:32 PM

Jul - The Cutting Room Floor - Mega Man Legacy Collection

Pages: 1 2

Next newer thread | Next older thread

Dickson
Member
Level: 17

Posts: 54/58
EXP: 20290
For next: 4453

Since: 07-16-12

Since last post: 214 days
Last activity: 139 days

Posted on 08-26-15 06:23:53 PM

Link | Quote

Two discoveries - the game's root folder is oddly called "Suzy" and the executable is "Proteus.exe"

That's all I got. Really curious if someone can find some interesting things, like removed games or features.

Xkeeper

Level: 243

Posts: 21615/23358
EXP: 224380482
For next: 2535138

Since: 07-03-07

Pronouns: they/them, she/her, etc.

Since last post: 7 hours
Last activity: 6 hours

Posted on 08-26-15 06:31:15 PM

Link | Quote

Suzy is just a name for the wall-sticking +-shaped robots, that's nothing too exciting.

metalman
User
Level: 8

Posts: 8/10
EXP: 1588
For next: 599

Since: 05-30-11

Since last post: 2.0 years
Last activity: 2.0 years

Posted on 08-26-15 09:17:10 PM

Link | Quote

https://www.reddit.com/r/Megaman/comments/3igzxk/mega_man_legacy_collection_is_a_fancy_emulator/

I wonder if this is true... (Same with the PS1 version of Chrono Trigger?)

2Tie

Rumours of my death have been greatly exaggerated.
Level: 61

Posts: 755/1047
EXP: 1850910
For next: 25686

Since: 02-22-10

Pronouns: anything you want
From: The Codrex, Karda Nui

Since last post: 14 days
Last activity: 9 hours

Posted on 08-26-15 09:24:12 PM

Link | Quote

something to do to test that would be to null out the memory/most of the memory containing the mentioned MM2 rom and see if the game would still play? or just non-audio/visual sections?

Xkeeper

Level: 243

Posts: 21616/23358
EXP: 224380482
For next: 2535138

Since: 07-03-07

Pronouns: they/them, she/her, etc.

Since last post: 7 hours
Last activity: 6 hours

Posted on 08-27-15 04:13:43 AM

Link | Quote

"data.pie" is actually a .zip file with AES encryption. The password is
"P091uWEdwe4lI6StDNMNlkodPGvJ38bL3HW6t3BCMYdFi83FXKu7k0NsHP8caDKS".

The internal name for the game is "Bakesale".

scripts/config.lua

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- DebugSettings.show_pattern_table = false DebugSettings.infinite_health = false DebugSettings.infinite_lives = false DebugSettings.debug_game_text = true DebugSettings.debug_challenge_text = false DebugSettings.autosave = false DebugSettings.left_stick_unlock_weapons = false DebugSettings.debug_weapons = false --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Setting these all to true and recompressing doesn't seem to have any obvious effects. Sad.

The challenges are all savestates, with probably some extra unknown code on how those work. Still looking into things with Ninji/CyberKitsune's help.

einstein95
Member
Level: 34

Posts: 221/313
EXP: 237646
For next: 16005

Since: 04-11-13

Since last post: 4 days
Last activity: 2 hours

Posted on 08-27-15 05:40:20 AM

Link | Quote

Roms are basically identical to the standard roms (as far as I have checked), but with the Nintendo copyright text removed in the most hacky way possible: Replacing it with spaces. The roms themselves are headerless and in the rdata portion of the exe. NSFs seem identical (as to be expected), and are also headerless. No idea why.

Xkeeper

Level: 243

Posts: 21618/23358
EXP: 224380482
For next: 2535138

Since: 07-03-07

Pronouns: they/them, she/her, etc.

Since last post: 7 hours
Last activity: 6 hours

Posted on 08-27-15 06:01:54 AM

Link | Quote

Probably to make their iNES-ness a little less obvious.

The ROMs seem to be split in reverse, too, with CHR coming before PRG. Ordinarily it's the opposite.

Krvavi Abadas

Red Goomba
Level: 12

Posts: 30/36
EXP: 7805
For next: 116

Since: 09-28-14

Since last post: 2.0 years
Last activity: 2.0 years

Posted on 08-27-15 12:20:16 PM

Link | Quote

Originally posted by metalman
https://www.reddit.com/r/Megaman/comments/3igzxk/mega_man_legacy_collection_is_a_fancy_emulator/

I wonder if this is true... (Same with the PS1 version of Chrono Trigger?)

It is, but not in the way you think.

In terms of how the game works internally. All of the graphics, Music, and stage layouts are directly loaded from the headerless roms. While the actual game code is directly ported into the Eclipse Format, which that new "Elcipse Version" code is then run on the PC/PS4/Xbox One/3DS versions of the Eclipse Engine. This means that basically, all ROM hacks that only modify those specific parts (Like the one shown in the Webm) will actually load in-game. While hacks that actually directly modify the games ASM code don't work.
Also, the challenges use completely custom code that's layered directly on top of the original ported code for stuff like the timer and the portals that teleport Mega Man to a different location (or a different game entirely in some of the challenges.)

The best part? This stuff was actually known before release. The former came from this USgamer interview

Originally posted by "Frank Cifaldi"
We set up our Eclipse Engine, and we set up hardware simulation modules, and we convert using source elements provided by the publisher, — their original game to our format.

While it's bit coy on the subject, it's pretty obvious what "using source elements" is referring to. Now that we have a proper analysis of how the game works. As for where the info about how the challenges work came from. It's from this video interview.

Originally posted by "Frank Cifaldi"
The challenge mode? We did not alter anything, that's all things that we're running on top of the original games

Originally posted by "Frank Cifaldi"
So when you start here, that's a save point that i've created, so there's no modification of code necessary for that. Those portals? Those were very difficult to implement but we got them working. We're drawing that portal on top of the game but also within the game's space so it's the same resolution and everything, and what we're doing is we can track where Mega Man's head is in the game, and we kinda know like when his head touches that portal. So like when you touch a portal it takes you to the next segment.

Unfortunately, it doesn't sound like the eclipse engine version is a perfect recreation like it's being promoted as. Supposedly, there's some minor audio issues. But it's definitely not on the same level as the fake "DIGITAL ECLIPSE IS LYING! THEY'RE JUST USING AN EMULATOR!" issue folks are getting mad about.

Xkeeper

Level: 243

Posts: 21619/23358
EXP: 224380482
For next: 2535138

Since: 07-03-07

Pronouns: they/them, she/her, etc.

Since last post: 7 hours
Last activity: 6 hours

Posted on 08-27-15 12:42:50 PM

Link | Quote

"Minor audio issues" is to be expected, since the source audio is rendered at like 1Mhz+ and you're usually only going to get 44khz out of most systems.

I wonder what emulator they used as a basis for their work.

Eon

Hammer Brother
MLB
Level: 64

Posts: 1046/1066
EXP: 2182334
For next: 31763

Since: 07-22-07

Since last post: 55 days
Last activity: 42 days

Posted on 08-28-15 02:08:57 AM

Link | Quote

Interesting. In a way I've played devil's advocate, by treating this collection under the assumption it was ported from source. The jury is still out on that one. They didn't say whether they had access to the actual original code, or whether it's been lost.

Krvavi Abadas' description makes me think of Doom source ports, in how the engine and audiovisual assets were treated separately.

einstein95
Member
Level: 34

Posts: 222/313
EXP: 237646
For next: 16005

Since: 04-11-13

Since last post: 4 days
Last activity: 2 hours

Posted on 08-28-15 02:06:43 PM

Link | Quote

Originally posted by Xkeeper
Probably to make their iNES-ness a little less obvious.

The ROMs seem to be split in reverse, too, with CHR coming before PRG. Ordinarily it's the opposite.

Didn't notice that with MM2 and 1.

Xkeeper

Level: 243

Posts: 21620/23358
EXP: 224380482
For next: 2535138

Since: 07-03-07

Pronouns: they/them, she/her, etc.

Since last post: 7 hours
Last activity: 6 hours

Posted on 08-28-15 03:30:06 PM

Link | Quote

MM3 and 4 definitely are.

In a way I've played devil's advocate, by treating this collection under the assumption it was ported from source.

Source wouldn't do you a whole lot of good for something like the NES, because the way it works is entirely different from any modern arch. You'd have to still include mechanisms for how the PPU works, how interrupts work, etc. Even things like timing.

Foxhack
Member
Annoying fuzzball
Level: 49

Posts: 625/701
EXP: 870565
For next: 13318

Since: 04-17-12

From: Mexicali, Mexico

Since last post: 17 days
Last activity: 6 min.

Posted on 08-29-15 05:17:53 PM (last edited by Foxhack at 08-29-15 05:18:42 PM)

Link | Quote

Has Digital Eclipse ever used other emulators as a base for their uh, work? As far as I knew they did all their things in-house.

The whole "Savestates" thing reminds me a lot of Terminal Reality's utterly craptacular The King of Fighters: The Orochi Saga "ports" on the PS2 and its challenge mode. They basically loaded a savestate and checked for specific things to happen to mark the challenge as done once you did it.

Now I'm starting to wonder if there's any staff overlap between Terminal Reality and this new company... since TR went out of business a few years ago.

Aceearly1993
Random nobody
Level: 7

Posts: 6/9
EXP: 1025
For next: 423

Since: 05-14-14

Since last post: 1.0 years
Last activity: 2 days

Posted on 08-30-15 06:54:30 AM (last edited by Aceearly1993 at 08-30-15 08:22:08 AM)

Link | Quote

Played ripped versions and get through MM3. I don't think there are any difference (actually, this version is MORE laggier than the versions on NES/FC emulators on some PCs in specific areas, like the bee hive area at the very start of Hard Man stage; when the bee throw its hive to the ground, the hive breaks, small bees burst out and create TONS of lag) But other structures like Yellow Devil fight seems to have no problem though. And it seems to be no additiolal bonus when a game was beaten (aside from the trophy/achievement stuff in console/steam that some people don't care about them at all)

Suzy is an enemy form Mega Man 1 ,dubbed "Octopus Battery" overseas

Also, is there any evidence that would reveal future plan, like probably (I don't think it's very possible though) DLCs?

ICEknight
Member
Level: 24

Posts: 111/135
EXP: 76447
For next: 1678

Since: 10-25-11

Since last post: 24 days
Last activity: 14 days

Posted on 09-08-15 04:30:54 AM

Link | Quote

Originally posted by Aceearly1993
Played ripped versions and get through MM3. I don't think there are any difference (actually, this version is MORE laggier than the versions on NES/FC emulators on some PCs in specific areas, like the bee hive area at the very start of Hard Man stage; when the bee throw its hive to the ground, the hive breaks, small bees burst out and create TONS of lag)

"Played ripped versions"? You mean you're playing that ROM that somebody mentioned is identical except for the Nintendo copyright being replaced by spaces?

Aceearly1993
Random nobody
Level: 7

Posts: 7/9
EXP: 1025
For next: 423

Since: 05-14-14

Since last post: 1.0 years
Last activity: 2 days

Posted on 09-09-15 10:58:42 AM (last edited by Aceearly1993 at 09-09-15 11:03:25 AM)

Link | Quote

Originally posted by ICEknight

"Played ripped versions"? You mean you're playing that ROM that somebody mentioned is identical except for the Nintendo copyright being replaced by spaces?

No, it labled "ripped" but I checked, it's the PC version of the game that got rid of all steam content

I have no direct evidence, but I think the Mega Man 3 part was 100% identical to the emulated version on NES/FC emulator, since the "Call Rush Jet from Shadow Blade" trick was in place (I'm not sure if 2P tricks form the original still work there because the game only supports XBOX360 controller (beside keyboard control) in my "ripped" PC version)

The file size of the game data is about 380+m~400+m, at first I think the PS remix version of music would be in place since I watched some videos that contain Mega Man 3 title music in PS1 navi mode, but I feel like that I was being cheated because only main menu of the game has remixed music from PS1 version navi mode, and the lack of content after beating a game.

Foxhack
Member
Annoying fuzzball
Level: 49

Posts: 628/701
EXP: 870565
For next: 13318

Since: 04-17-12

From: Mexicali, Mexico

Since last post: 17 days
Last activity: 6 min.

Posted on 09-09-15 08:45:24 PM (last edited by Foxhack at 09-09-15 08:46:11 PM)

Link | Quote

Oh, so it's a cracked, hacked version.

"Ripped", in those terms, usually means that they remove files or replace them with lower quality ones just to save space.

einstein95
Member
Level: 34

Posts: 302/313
EXP: 237646
For next: 16005

Since: 04-11-13

Since last post: 4 days
Last activity: 2 hours

Posted on 08-13-17 08:42:28 AM (last edited by einstein95 at 08-13-17 08:56:02 AM)

Link | Quote

Bumping this as Legacy Collection 2 has been released. Files are contained in "disc" which is a password-encrypted ZIP file, where have we heard that before?

If someone wants to get the password, the files are here: https://mega.nz/#F!Fod0mYyR!tEMFY8xYoNg-OtfGkdDUgw

Xeo
Member
Level: 23

Posts: 97/97
EXP: 59851
For next: 7872

Since: 07-28-07

Since last post: 256 days
Last activity: 74 days

Posted on 08-13-17 12:40:10 PM

Link | Quote

I've never liked Mega Man 7-8 much, but they're still fine. It's been so long since I've played them though I'm actually excited to give them another run.

I still think Mega Man & Bass should have been on this set, which I think outclasses both 7-8 for that era.

9-10 are awesome and I still haven't played those much, so it'll also be fun giving them another run!

rabidabid
Member
Level: 23

Posts: 111/114
EXP: 64418
For next: 3305

Since: 08-25-10

Since last post: 77 days
Last activity: 1 day

Posted on 08-17-17 11:31:57 PM (last edited by rabidabid at 08-17-17 11:39:15 PM)

Link | Quote

Portion of Nintendo 3DS Code Found Inside Mega Man Legacy Collection 2

Also the background Famicoms and hidden Game Boy in Junk Man's stage have been removed. Probably worth documenting as a revisional difference.

Pages: 1 2

Next newer thread | Next older thread

Jul - The Cutting Room Floor - Mega Man Legacy Collection

Rusted Logic

36 database queries, 4 query cache hits.

Query execution time:	0.208060 seconds
Script execution time:	0.080380 seconds
Total render time:	0.288440 seconds
Memory used:	1048576