Register - Login
Views: 88969133
Main - Memberlist - Active users - Calendar - Wiki - IRC Chat - Online users
Ranks - Rules/FAQ - Stats - Latest Posts - Color Chart - Smilies
02-22-18 08:07:32 AM

Jul - Display Case - Mafia V: Round 9 New poll - New thread - Thread closed
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7Next newer thread | Next older thread
Nksor

Buster Beetle
Level: 42


Posts: 364/472
EXP: 512046
For next: 9316

Since: 04-26-11
From: The Void

Since last post: 1.0 years
Last activity: 1.0 years

Posted on 01-15-12 04:11:57 PM Link
It's also worth noting, about how Girly says that Ramon told him that he was the Insomniac because he saw that Girly was setting traps...

Did you all forget about the temporary investigation rule?

So yeah, hopefully that reinforces my argument.

In the case that it wasn't clear earlier, my final vote is Ramon.
Girlydragon
2930
Possibly neither Girly nor Dragon.
Level: 99


Posts: 2336/2935
EXP: 9890406
For next: 109594

Since: 07-21-07
From: Sweden

Since last post: 3 days
Last activity: 8 hours

Posted on 01-15-12 04:14:03 PM Link
From what I understand investigating takes up a night.

There was no night without a kill until Ramon contacted me.

So uh, yeah, assuming I didn't misunderstand the rule.
Ramon
Member
Level: 36


Posts: 245/294
EXP: 299664
For next: 8446

Since: 06-20-08


Since last post: 1.0 years
Last activity: 362 days

Posted on 01-15-12 05:30:00 PM (last edited by Ramon at 01-15-12 05:31 PM) Link
Uhm, okay, that's kind of a wordwar going on here. First of all, with BlueWhirl apparently revealing himself as the Insomniac, he's proven to be lying. He's either thug or the Godfather. I'm going to vote BlueWhirl nevertheless, as if he's the thug, we have confirmation that Snowdeath is the Godfather.

Girlydragon has pretty much summarized nearly everything - at Night 2, Nicole AND Girlydragon visited my room (and I heard activity in Stark's room, because (s)he was killed) - which lead to the doctor's death.
Prior to that, though, I had a little conversation with legacyme3 - about how I found it odd that the game was on hold due to silverthundr's inactivity until he came back online. The reason I PMed him was because I didn't hear any activity from either of the rooms next to me in Night 1, so neither Stark nor legacyme3 could be Mafia or Godfather. They could still be the thug though, but the thugs don't know the Mafia Members. Then we somehow met the topic of him being the thug, and he gave an odd response: that he loves being the thug. So that either meant he was the thug, or a bystander.
I responded to silverthundr's previous statement with the Trapper question, because if he did admit it it would be obvious he'd be lying, but right now, I'm pretty sure he is who he claims to be - not only due to there not being any counterclaim.

Whichever it is, it'll be no use for the thug to take the bullet anymore, because we have yet another day to lynch the Godfather.

It's a win-win situation! Of course only if everybody votes for BlueWhirl, as the thug could still support the counter-lynch.

tl;dr: I'm the Insomniac, Girlydragon the Trapper, legacyme3 is not the Godfather, silverthundr is the Sheriff. If BlueWhirl was Bystander, there'd be no reason to lie. So BlueWhirl definitely is Godfather/Thug, and if he's the Thug, there's only Snowdeath left.

Originally posted by BlueWhirl
It's also worth noting, about how Girly says that Ramon told him that he was the Insomniac because he saw that Girly was setting traps...

Did you all forget about the temporary investigation rule?

So yeah, hopefully that reinforces my argument.

In the case that it wasn't clear earlier, my final vote is Ramon.


In fact, due to what Girlydragon has already stated, you just confirmed to be lying
legacyme3
"In short, legacyme3 does horrible things to people, and I don't think anyone else on Jul should be exposed to him, no matter how decent of a person he pretends to be."

I don't normally ban for offsite behavior but you're a whole level of terrible.
Level: NaN


Posts: 1166/-1694
EXP: NaN
For next: 0

Since: 06-01-11


Since last post: 4.0 years
Last activity: 219 days

Posted on 01-15-12 05:30:25 PM (last edited by legacyme3 at 01-15-12 05:32 PM) Link
I've read all this.

I'm going to reveal this now.

Ramon contacted me within the first few days.

If he is the godfather, score, he was a little tricky.

I think it's more likely that he is the thug.

I think Snowdeath could be the godfather if Ramon is not. I'll recap below.

Snowdeath hates hates hates the godfather role. Or does she? It's no secret that this isn't the most telling evidence, but, wouldn't it just be a sublime play to hate the godfather role on another site, so they could play it off on a site they like more? Wouldn't you be willing to sacrifice little to get more on a grander scale?

Ramon/Snowdeath is Godfather/thug. If we miss today, we'll hit tomorrow.

In case it isn't clear, I'm voting Snowdeath
Ramon
Member
Level: 36


Posts: 246/294
EXP: 299664
For next: 8446

Since: 06-20-08


Since last post: 1.0 years
Last activity: 362 days

Posted on 01-15-12 05:38:33 PM Link
@legacyme3: I believe this is a mistake. BlueWhirl is confirmed to be lying, we have a 100% chance to hit a Mafia-sided player here. Snowdeath isn't really confirmed to be Mafia - she'd only be Mafia due to process of elimination.
legacyme3
"In short, legacyme3 does horrible things to people, and I don't think anyone else on Jul should be exposed to him, no matter how decent of a person he pretends to be."

I don't normally ban for offsite behavior but you're a whole level of terrible.
Level: NaN


Posts: 1167/-1694
EXP: NaN
For next: 0

Since: 06-01-11


Since last post: 4.0 years
Last activity: 219 days

Posted on 01-15-12 05:41:27 PM Link
Originally posted by Ramon
@legacyme3: I believe this is a mistake. BlueWhirl is confirmed to be lying, we have a 100% chance to hit a Mafia-sided player here. Snowdeath isn't really confirmed to be Mafia - she'd only be Mafia due to process of elimination.


Is this the accusation round?

I already accused BlueWhirl and silverthundr earlier in the round.

Now I want to REMOVE my accusation on silverthundr, and accuse Snowdeath as well.

I'm putting forward, in total BlueWhirl and Snowdeath the LIKELY godfather/thug pairing.
Nksor

Buster Beetle
Level: 42


Posts: 365/472
EXP: 512046
For next: 9316

Since: 04-26-11
From: The Void

Since last post: 1.0 years
Last activity: 1.0 years

Posted on 01-15-12 06:29:42 PM Link
Ok - I admit it, I was lying.

I'm actually the bystander, in this game.

Why did I mix up the roles on purpose?

So that you guys would be at your throats.

Look, nobody had any leads on anybody. We now know who everyone is. My bait and switch worked perfectly. I managed to get everyone to accuse each other. One by one, everyone explained and outlined their roles.

That is, except for two people: Snowdeath, and legacyme3.

I may have made enemies out of a lot of you, but I took this game from absolute clueless guesses to absolute certainty. I have given this game a 100% chance of a win for the bystanders.

@legacyme3: I've been watching you, carefully. You haven't been too clear about your role. When people try to talk you into things, you go "ok, cool". You've been riding along this entire time, just waiting to jump to protect your fellow Mafioso, Snowdeath. Your accusation of her is an attempt by you to give us all the smoke screen - except I can see through the petty little tricks. As soon as the kill round came up - you would switch instantly to accusing me. Once I died, the balance of power would have shifted to the scum. But I caught you, at the final moment.

This is the final role list I've compiled, no shits this time.

FINAL ROLE LIST-


  • Bystander - BlueWhirl

  • The Sheriff - silverthundr

  • Thug - legacyme3

  • The Trapper - Girlydragon

  • The Godfather - Snowdeath

  • The Insomniac - Ramon



*BlueWhirl bows
legacyme3
"In short, legacyme3 does horrible things to people, and I don't think anyone else on Jul should be exposed to him, no matter how decent of a person he pretends to be."

I don't normally ban for offsite behavior but you're a whole level of terrible.
Level: NaN


Posts: 1168/-1694
EXP: NaN
For next: 0

Since: 06-01-11


Since last post: 4.0 years
Last activity: 219 days

Posted on 01-15-12 06:33:18 PM Link
Originally posted by BlueWhirl
Ok - I admit it, I was lying.

I'm actually the bystander, in this game.




Bullshit.
Nksor

Buster Beetle
Level: 42


Posts: 366/472
EXP: 512046
For next: 9316

Since: 04-26-11
From: The Void

Since last post: 1.0 years
Last activity: 1.0 years

Posted on 01-15-12 06:34:08 PM (last edited by BlueWhirl at 01-18-12 10:40 PM) Link
Originally posted by legacyme3
Bullshit.


I love how you used actual logic there.
Girlydragon
2930
Possibly neither Girly nor Dragon.
Level: 99


Posts: 2337/2935
EXP: 9890406
For next: 109594

Since: 07-21-07
From: Sweden

Since last post: 3 days
Last activity: 8 hours

Posted on 01-15-12 06:34:28 PM Link
Originally posted by legacyme3
Originally posted by BlueWhirl
Ok - I admit it, I was lying.

I'm actually the bystander, in this game.




Bullshit.
legacyme3
"In short, legacyme3 does horrible things to people, and I don't think anyone else on Jul should be exposed to him, no matter how decent of a person he pretends to be."

I don't normally ban for offsite behavior but you're a whole level of terrible.
Level: NaN


Posts: 1169/-1694
EXP: NaN
For next: 0

Since: 06-01-11


Since last post: 4.0 years
Last activity: 219 days

Posted on 01-15-12 06:39:37 PM Link
You know. The funny thing is. I don't have to be clear on my role, since you keep flipflopping roles.

Fuck your logic.

Regardless of "intent" I am now more concerned about you than Snowdeath.

So fuck my accusation on Snowdeath.

Final Accusation

BlueWhirl.

Rot in hell Godfather/Thug.
Nksor

Buster Beetle
Level: 42


Posts: 367/472
EXP: 512046
For next: 9316

Since: 04-26-11
From: The Void

Since last post: 1.0 years
Last activity: 1.0 years

Posted on 01-15-12 06:40:57 PM Link
I think you're making the wrong decision...

...or, the right decision, at least for your side.
legacyme3
"In short, legacyme3 does horrible things to people, and I don't think anyone else on Jul should be exposed to him, no matter how decent of a person he pretends to be."

I don't normally ban for offsite behavior but you're a whole level of terrible.
Level: NaN


Posts: 1170/-1694
EXP: NaN
For next: 0

Since: 06-01-11


Since last post: 4.0 years
Last activity: 219 days

Posted on 01-15-12 06:41:31 PM Link
Originally posted by BlueWhirl
I think you're making the wrong decision...

...or, the right decision, at least for your side.


Idle Chatter be idle.

Quiet you. Go to your gallows.
Nksor

Buster Beetle
Level: 42


Posts: 368/472
EXP: 512046
For next: 9316

Since: 04-26-11
From: The Void

Since last post: 1.0 years
Last activity: 1.0 years

Posted on 01-15-12 06:46:12 PM Link
Even though it seems evident that you guys are certain that I must be a member of the scum, even though I'm the one who actually gave reasons for my deceiving, unlike legacyme3, who still has yet to provide any evidence for his argument...

Is there any solid reason as to -why- I'm most definitely a member of the scum?
legacyme3
"In short, legacyme3 does horrible things to people, and I don't think anyone else on Jul should be exposed to him, no matter how decent of a person he pretends to be."

I don't normally ban for offsite behavior but you're a whole level of terrible.
Level: NaN


Posts: 1171/-1694
EXP: NaN
For next: 0

Since: 06-01-11


Since last post: 4.0 years
Last activity: 219 days

Posted on 01-15-12 06:48:16 PM Link
Originally posted by BlueWhirl
unlike legacyme3, who still has yet to provide any evidence for his argument...


Evidence for you being Mafia - Flip Flopping roles. Liar.

Evidence for me not being Mafia - Having absolutely nothing to do. Also, having nothing to lose from actually helping along discussion.
Girlydragon
2930
Possibly neither Girly nor Dragon.
Level: 99


Posts: 2338/2935
EXP: 9890406
For next: 109594

Since: 07-21-07
From: Sweden

Since last post: 3 days
Last activity: 8 hours

Posted on 01-15-12 06:48:58 PM Link
Originally posted by BlueWhirl
Is there any solid reason as to -why- I'm most definitely a member of the scum?



I... Thiiiink.

It's the part where you lied.

Yes.

And the part where you are really overly defensive and are pulling at straws.



But mostly, lies.
Nksor

Buster Beetle
Level: 42


Posts: 369/472
EXP: 512046
For next: 9316

Since: 04-26-11
From: The Void

Since last post: 1.0 years
Last activity: 1.0 years

Posted on 01-15-12 06:54:38 PM Link
Oh, so it's like you've never seen someone pull a bait and switch before? huh. Lying is part of mafia, it happens every single round. Not every liar is mafia, you know.

Please let me know who you guys would have voted off before I started all of this. Oh wait, you would have just made aimless guesses.

I was overly defensive and picking at straws in my fake form, my Insomniac form. And that was on purpose, if you actually read what I stated a few posts up.

I'm now really me, and the only reason I've been pecking at you guys is because I haven't gotten any response to my fearless endeavors which was for you guys other than "well I won't believe you because I'm stubborn and I can't realize that you've been doing that on purpose. disregard all evidence, you lied and all liars lie because they're Mafia!"
legacyme3
"In short, legacyme3 does horrible things to people, and I don't think anyone else on Jul should be exposed to him, no matter how decent of a person he pretends to be."

I don't normally ban for offsite behavior but you're a whole level of terrible.
Level: NaN


Posts: 1172/-1694
EXP: NaN
For next: 0

Since: 06-01-11


Since last post: 4.0 years
Last activity: 219 days

Posted on 01-15-12 06:56:15 PM Link
Originally posted by BlueWhirl

Please let me know who you guys would have voted off before I started all of this. Oh wait, you would have just made aimless guesses.



Either you or Silverthundr. You were both fishy to me. However, "thanks" to you, I know silver is likely innocent, and YOU are DEFINITELY a thug/godfather.

Sukasa

Dances with Ponies
Level: 117


Posts: 3623/4280
EXP: 17448551
For next: 399344

Since: 07-07-07


Since last post: 3.0 years
Last activity: 3.0 years

Posted on 01-15-12 06:57:54 PM Link
Just so you all know, I wait at least 24-48 hours between getting the last night-round PMs and posting.

Anyways, time for final voting.

Your options are:

1. BlueWhirl
2. Snowdeath
3. Ramon
4. legacyme3
Nksor

Buster Beetle
Level: 42


Posts: 370/472
EXP: 512046
For next: 9316

Since: 04-26-11
From: The Void

Since last post: 1.0 years
Last activity: 1.0 years

Posted on 01-15-12 06:59:34 PM Link
Originally posted by legacyme3
YOU are DEFINITELY a thug/godfather.


can you even

read

There is NO evidence towards me being a thug or the godfather.

All I ask for is that you guys don't kill me. If anything, kill Snowdeath. If she's not a thug or the godfather, then I give you guys full permission to just nuke me.

I choose to kill Snowdeath.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7Next newer thread | Next older thread
Jul - Display Case - Mafia V: Round 9 New poll - New thread - Thread closed




Rusted Logic

Acmlmboard - commit 25b5dc1 [2018-02-01]
©2000-2018 Acmlm, Xkeeper, Inuyasha, et al.

28 database queries, 7 query cache hits.
Query execution time: 0.228837 seconds
Script execution time: 0.045351 seconds
Total render time: 0.274188 seconds