Register - Login
Views: 93280119
Main - Memberlist - Active users - Calendar - Wiki - IRC Chat - Online users
Ranks - Rules/FAQ - Stats - Latest Posts - Color Chart - Smilies
07-20-18 02:38:51 AM

Jul - Display Case - Mafia V: Round 8 New poll - New thread - Thread closed
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14Next newer thread | Next older thread
Ramon
Member
Level: 36


Posts: 159/294
EXP: 305863
For next: 2247

Since: 06-20-08


Since last post: 2.0 years
Last activity: 1.0 years

Posted on 09-24-11 02:50:52 PM Link
I don't have a lot of clue right now as to what's happening, though I don't really see Paranoia as very suspicious. Girlydragon sticks out much more to me, somehow. Something about his choice of words just strikes me.

I wish I had more to say right now, but reading all of those last posts made my mind go blank somehow.
Q
Seeker of the tru7h
Level: 99


Posts: 2262/2871
EXP: 9734312
For next: 265688

Since: 08-02-07

Pronouns: she/her
From: Nowhere

Since last post: 1 day
Last activity: 1 hour

Posted on 09-25-11 09:19:18 PM Link
Well, Paranoia, it was close, but you're the first victim of the game.

It's a shame that you were just a bystander all along.

List O' Players: (Mafia to Bystanders - 3:11)
1. Sukasa
2. krutomisi
3. Ramon
4. MaxKnight
5. Snowdeath
6. Stark
7. Paranoia
8. MM200
9. Sanky
10. Girlydragon
11. Kirby Mario
12. legacyme3
13. Imajin
14. CB
15. silverthundr

List O' Positions:
Bystanders (5)
Mafia (2)
The Doctor
The Sheriff
Thugs (2)
The Trapper
The Godfather
The Insomniac

Now that the ice has been broken, will the Mafia proceed with their first kill as well, or will they simply continue to gather information? Tune in next time to find out!
CB

Flippitty Flip
Level: 85


Posts: 2210/2280
EXP: 5684237
For next: 214303

Since: 01-31-11

From: Canadaland

Since last post: 6.0 years
Last activity: 6.0 years

Posted on 09-25-11 10:04:11 PM (last edited by CB at 09-25-11 10:40 PM) Link

...
...
...


EDIT: This group is like a cobra,
Blindly lashing out at whatever opposes it
in the misguided belief that it cannot miss,
yet always biting its own tail...
legacyme3
"In short, legacyme3 does horrible things to people, and I don't think anyone else on Jul should be exposed to him, no matter how decent of a person he pretends to be."

I don't normally ban for offsite behavior but you're a whole level of terrible.
Level: NaN


Posts: 562/-1694
EXP: NaN
For next: 0

Since: 06-01-11


Since last post: 5.0 years
Last activity: 18 days

Posted on 09-25-11 10:11:19 PM Link
Derp. Can't be helped =/

He was more or less asking for it eventually.
Sanqui
1720
🦉
Level: 77


Posts: 1016/1729
EXP: 4024683
For next: 166446

Since: 12-20-09

Pronouns: any
From: Czechia (NEW!)

Since last post: 33 days
Last activity: 15 hours

Posted on 09-26-11 04:15:34 AM Link
Wahwhat.

My deduction skills suck.
I'll just stay quiet throughout the night and day, okay?
legacyme3
"In short, legacyme3 does horrible things to people, and I don't think anyone else on Jul should be exposed to him, no matter how decent of a person he pretends to be."

I don't normally ban for offsite behavior but you're a whole level of terrible.
Level: NaN


Posts: 563/-1694
EXP: NaN
For next: 0

Since: 06-01-11


Since last post: 5.0 years
Last activity: 18 days

Posted on 09-26-11 04:23:09 AM Link
Originally posted by Sanky
Wahwhat.

My deduction skills suck.
I'll just stay quiet throughout the night and day, okay?


That doesn't really help anyone. Even if they are wrong, you can provide us with information even if it's not right.

Don't be too worried about it.
Girlydragon
2940
Possibly neither Girly nor Dragon.
Level: 100


Posts: 2173/2941
EXP: 10108375
For next: 246021

Since: 07-21-07

From: Sweden

Since last post: 134 days
Last activity: 4 hours

Posted on 09-26-11 06:00:28 AM Link
Well, that sucked.
Ramon
Member
Level: 36


Posts: 161/294
EXP: 305863
For next: 2247

Since: 06-20-08


Since last post: 2.0 years
Last activity: 1.0 years

Posted on 09-26-11 06:15:49 AM Link
I know this now may sound a little contradictory, but the people who voted for Girlydragon are actually more likely to be Mafia. (No comment on me, I know I voted for him, but I wouldn't bring this up if I were Mafia.)
Paranoia was, you say, acting suspicious all the time already and thus the logical thing for the bystanders would be to vote him off. Mafia knows he isn't Mafia, so they try to vote somebody else to appear as "I didn't vote for Paranoia, who turned out to be a bystander" later on.

And Imajin, who voted no-kill yet again. CB also sticks out to me.
Nicole

Disk-kun
Level: 140


Posts: 5091/6443
EXP: 32836021
For next: 450384

Since: 07-06-07

Pronouns: she/her
From: Boston, MA

Since last post: 23 days
Last activity: 3 days

Posted on 09-26-11 02:53:10 PM Link
Originally posted by Ramon
I know this now may sound a little contradictory, but the people who voted for Girlydragon are actually more likely to be Mafia. (No comment on me, I know I voted for him, but I wouldn't bring this up if I were Mafia.)
Paranoia was, you say, acting suspicious all the time already and thus the logical thing for the bystanders would be to vote him off. Mafia knows he isn't Mafia, so they try to vote somebody else to appear as "I didn't vote for Paranoia, who turned out to be a bystander" later on.

And Imajin, who voted no-kill yet again. CB also sticks out to me.

"People who didn't vote for a bystander are more likely to be in the Mafia"

Yeah, I'm not following that logic.
CB

Flippitty Flip
Level: 85


Posts: 2214/2280
EXP: 5684237
For next: 214303

Since: 01-31-11

From: Canadaland

Since last post: 6.0 years
Last activity: 6.0 years

Posted on 09-26-11 06:17:05 PM Link
Originally posted by Ramon
I know this now may sound a little contradictory, but the people who voted for Girlydragon are actually more likely to be Mafia. (No comment on me, I know I voted for him, but I wouldn't bring this up if I were Mafia.)
Paranoia was, you say, acting suspicious all the time already and thus the logical thing for the bystanders would be to vote him off. Mafia knows he isn't Mafia, so they try to vote somebody else to appear as "I didn't vote for Paranoia, who turned out to be a bystander" later on.

And Imajin, who voted no-kill yet again. CB also sticks out to me.


Odds of us killing a mafia member by blindly voting = 20%
Odds of us killing a Bystander/Other Role = 80%

Yeah, not very good with logic there, are you?
Ramon
Member
Level: 36


Posts: 163/294
EXP: 305863
For next: 2247

Since: 06-20-08


Since last post: 2.0 years
Last activity: 1.0 years

Posted on 09-27-11 08:17:00 AM (last edited by Ramon at 09-27-11 08:17 AM) Link
Originally posted by CB
Odds of us killing a mafia member by blindly voting = 20%
Odds of us killing a Bystander/Other Role = 80%

Yeah, not very good with logic there, are you?


You keep thinking in percentages, I've (and others) explained often enough why no-kill is a bad idea.

See it this way: no-kill: Chance of killing Mafia: 0%
Adelheid

Level: 40


Posts: 182/422
EXP: 436054
For next: 5255

Since: 08-15-11

From: Redmond, WA

Since last post: 4.0 years
Last activity: 4.0 years

Posted on 09-27-11 08:29:15 AM (last edited by Stark at 09-27-11 08:29 AM) Link
On the one hand, it doesn't make a lot of sense to let the mafia control the pace of the game. This is a fair statement. Vut on the other hand, this is an open game and we know all the roles and we know the mafia doesn't have anyone who can detect roles, or the like. As long as no one's killing anyone, that is purely to the town's advantage, since we still have a sheriff.
silverthundr
160
Level: 27


Posts: 40/166
EXP: 107831
For next: 8328

Since: 08-04-11

From: Oregon

Since last post: 5.0 years
Last activity: 4.0 years

Posted on 09-27-11 10:48:09 AM Link
Originally posted by Stark
On the one hand, it doesn't make a lot of sense to let the mafia control the pace of the game. This is a fair statement. Vut on the other hand, this is an open game and we know all the roles and we know the mafia doesn't have anyone who can detect roles, or the like. As long as no one's killing anyone, that is purely to the town's advantage, since we still have a sheriff.


Actually, that is exactly what they've been doing. Mafia investigating tells them the role of that person. So yeah, if they eventually know all of the roles, it's going to be a problem.

Oh, and this :

Originally posted by Ramon
I know this now may sound a little contradictory, but the people who voted for Girlydragon are actually more likely to be Mafia. (No comment on me, I know I voted for him, but I wouldn't bring this up if I were Mafia.)
Paranoia was, you say, acting suspicious all the time already and thus the logical thing for the bystanders would be to vote him off. Mafia knows he isn't Mafia, so they try to vote somebody else to appear as "I didn't vote for Paranoia, who turned out to be a bystander" later on.

And Imajin, who voted no-kill yet again. CB also sticks out to me.


I get the logic, but especially with "I wouldn't bring this up if I was Mafia" bit, it makes you just as suspicious.

Of course, it's probably a better idea to wait until the day round before we get on with this sort of talk, but whatever.
Adelheid

Level: 40


Posts: 184/422
EXP: 436054
For next: 5255

Since: 08-15-11

From: Redmond, WA

Since last post: 4.0 years
Last activity: 4.0 years

Posted on 09-27-11 10:54:01 AM Link
My bad. I guess I missed that when reading the rules. It's not an ability native to the ganes I'm used to.

Well in that case, since they have a smaller pool of people to look through and three possible targets, things would definitely seem to be against town favor in investigation...

So no kill would be a bad idea. Heh. Okay.
legacyme3
"In short, legacyme3 does horrible things to people, and I don't think anyone else on Jul should be exposed to him, no matter how decent of a person he pretends to be."

I don't normally ban for offsite behavior but you're a whole level of terrible.
Level: NaN


Posts: 588/-1694
EXP: NaN
For next: 0

Since: 06-01-11


Since last post: 5.0 years
Last activity: 18 days

Posted on 09-29-11 01:45:14 AM Link
I guess that we are still sleeping?
Q
Seeker of the tru7h
Level: 99


Posts: 2264/2871
EXP: 9734312
For next: 265688

Since: 08-02-07

Pronouns: she/her
From: Nowhere

Since last post: 1 day
Last activity: 1 hour

Posted on 09-29-11 05:58:19 PM Link
Sorry for the delay, everyone. The PM-ing process went a bit slower than usual. Let's try to pick up the pace next time, alright?

Anyway, it should be no big surprise that nobody died in the night.

List O' Players: (Mafia to Bystanders - 3:11)
1. Sukasa
2. krutomisi
3. Ramon
4. MaxKnight
5. Snowdeath
6. Stark
7. Paranoia
8. MM200
9. Sanky
10. Girlydragon
11. Kirby Mario
12. legacyme3
13. Imajin
14. CB
15. silverthundr

List O' Positions:
Bystanders (5)
Mafia (2)
The Doctor
The Sheriff
Thugs (2)
The Trapper
The Godfather
The Insomniac

Let's get this up and running again.
CB

Flippitty Flip
Level: 85


Posts: 2221/2280
EXP: 5684237
For next: 214303

Since: 01-31-11

From: Canadaland

Since last post: 6.0 years
Last activity: 6.0 years

Posted on 09-29-11 06:01:58 PM Link
No-Kill

My reasons for this have not changed.
Girlydragon
2940
Possibly neither Girly nor Dragon.
Level: 100


Posts: 2178/2941
EXP: 10108375
For next: 246021

Since: 07-21-07

From: Sweden

Since last post: 134 days
Last activity: 4 hours

Posted on 09-29-11 06:11:59 PM Link
Ramon makes an interesting proposal with anyone voting for me having a bigger risk of being mafia, but I'm not really buying it, seems a little farfetched. On a whole other note, I have a few accusations to make.

CB:

Voting no-kill has been shown to not get us anywhere, and overly passive attitude will probably just bite us in the butt, I'm accusing you for being seemingly totally random in your accusations and voting, and holding us off. For example, last round you first accused paranoia after me, then voted me, and now you vote no-kill. Looks weird to me.

Stark:

Merely because anyone not keeping up with the investigation rule at the moment seem mysterious, and I believe it might be so that you feign ignorance in order to look innocent, because I do not believe someone like you would miss that important of a element. You may take it as a compliment if you so wish.

Ramon:

Making one group of persons seem more risky whilst you yourself is in that group seems like a deliberate form of reverse logic or some such, and it feels highly suspicious.



There are my accusation, take them however you want.
Sukasa

Dances with Ponies
Level: 117


Posts: 3378/4280
EXP: 17777356
For next: 70539

Since: 07-07-07


Since last post: 3.0 years
Last activity: 3.0 years

Posted on 09-29-11 06:13:40 PM Link
I would say that Stark of all people missing a rule is pretty surprising and out of character.
CB

Flippitty Flip
Level: 85


Posts: 2222/2280
EXP: 5684237
For next: 214303

Since: 01-31-11

From: Canadaland

Since last post: 6.0 years
Last activity: 6.0 years

Posted on 09-29-11 06:34:31 PM Link
Originally posted by Sukasa
I would say that Stark of all people missing a rule is pretty surprising and out of character.


In her defence though, the rules are rather scattered throughout the signup thread.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14Next newer thread | Next older thread
Jul - Display Case - Mafia V: Round 8 New poll - New thread - Thread closed




Rusted Logic

Acmlmboard - commit 5d36857 [2018-03-03]
©2000-2018 Acmlm, Xkeeper, Inuyasha, et al.

28 database queries, 5 query cache hits.
Query execution time: 0.183438 seconds
Script execution time: 0.029258 seconds
Total render time: 0.212696 seconds
Memory used: 1310720